3 Types of Espresso Machines: An Expert Guide on How to Choose an Espresso Maker

the espresso guide

Are you looking for the perfect shot of espresso to kickstart your mornings or elevate your after-dinner gatherings? Look no further! Selecting the best home espresso machine can seem like a daunting task, but armed with the right buying tips and research, you can find your perfect brew companion effortlessly. “Crate and Barrel has the best selection of top rated home espresso machines, curated in a way to eliminate the noise and confusion. An espresso machine can be an intimidating product to buy! But picking one can be rather easy if you know what you are looking for,” says lead kitchen electrics buyer at Crate & Barrel Nicole DuBois.

In this article, we’ll give a helpful overview of the world of home espresso machines to bring you expert guidance on choosing the ideal machine tailored to your preferences. Whether you're a novice espresso enthusiast or a seasoned barista, this guide is designed to assist you in how to choose an espresso machine.

the importance of choosing the right type of espresso machine

Choosing the best at home espresso machine is crucial in achieving the ultimate coffee experience that aligns with your lifestyle. Each type of espresso maker offers a distinct brewing method, influencing the taste, strength, aroma and convenience of your espresso. Understanding these differences empowers you to make an informed decision on selecting the right machine.

You’ll also want to consider factors such as brewing time, pressure, temperature control, ease of use, maintenance, boiler type (single boiler or dual boiler), types of grinders (like a built in grinder), price point and more when determining which machine suits you best.

Coffee Mugs

different types of espresso machines

“With espresso machines, there’s something for everyone,” says lead kitchen electrics buyer for Crate & Barrel Nicole DuBois. “You just need to decide how hands-on you want to be in the brewing process. If you want something that can make your favorite beverage at the push of a button, customized exactly the way you want it to be, you might like an automatic espresso machine. Or if you want that hands-on experience, have a little more time or want to experiment more, you’ll be thrilled with a semi-automatic machine.”

Read on to learn more about the differences and nuances of different types of the three different types of espresso machines.

Automatic espresso machine

automatic espresso machine

Automatic espresso machines are the epitome of convenience, offering fully automated brewing processes at the touch of a button. These machines typically feature built-in grinders, milk frothing and programmable settings for personalized espresso drinks. Differences among automatic machines often relate to the frothing capabilities and the number of drinks the machine can create. You will also hear these machines called fully automatic espresso machines and super automatic espresso machines.

USES
Automatic espresso machines are perfect for busy individuals seeking hassle-free espresso brewing without compromising on quality. They are ideal for those who value convenience and consistency in their daily espresso routine.

CLEANING INFO
These automatic or super automatic machines often come with self-cleaning functions to clean out various components. Regular descaling and cleaning of the milk frothing components according to manufacturer directions is recommended to ensure optimal performance.

PROS

  • Effortless brewing process

  • Consistent results

  • Programmable settings for personalized drinks

  • Less mess than other machines

  • Easy cleaning options in some, including automatic reminders

  • Can make a variety of drinks, from just a few to 35+

  • Great for beginners

CONS

  • Limited control over the brewing process

  • Higher initial investment

  • Takes up countertop space

  • Requires some routine maintenance like cleaning and dusting

POPULAR BRANDS AND MODELS

SHOP ALL AUTOMATIC ESPRESSO MACHINES

semi-automatic espresso machine

Semi-automatic espresso machines offer the perfect balance between automation and manual control. They require hands-on interaction for certain tasks like grinding coffee, tamping and frothing milk.

Differences among these machines include whether they have a built-in grinder or not, whether they have automatic frothing or not, and whether they offer tamp assist or not. Nicole DuBois, lead kitchen electrics buyer at Crate and Barrel says, “If you really care about the flavor of espresso, you’ll probably want a semi automatic machine so you can control all those elements.”

USES
Semi-automatic is ideal for espresso enthusiasts who enjoy the hands-on brewing process and desire more control over the final product. Semi-automatic machines allow for experimentation and customization to achieve the perfect shot of espresso.

CLEANING INFO
You will need to regularly clean the portafilter, group head, steam wand and other components to maintain optimal hygiene and flavor. Many semi-automatic machines come with removable parts for easy cleaning.

PROS

  • Greater control over the brewing process

  • Ability to customize

  • Suitable for both beginners and experienced users

  • Some have guided programs that can assist

  • Gives you the feeling of being your own barista

  • Makes it fun to entertain and is a showstopper in your home

CONS

  • Learning curve for beginners

  • Requires some hands-on effort for each shot

  • A little messier than fully automatic

  • Needs some routine maintenance (although typically less than automatic)

  • Takes a few minutes to pull a shot and make a drink

POPULAR BRANDS AND MODELS

SHOP ALL SEMI-AUTOMATIC ESPRESSO MACHINES

semo-automatic espresso machines
manual espresso machines

manual espresso machine

Manual espresso machines, also known as lever machines, rely on human-powered pressure to extract espresso. They offer the ultimate hands-on brewing experience, allowing users to control every aspect of the extraction process.

Notably, some people use the term “manual” to also describe semi automatic machines since they have a hands-on component to them, often ones that do not have an on-board grinder. You may also find stovetop espresso makers like the Moka Pot referred to as manual.

USES
Manual espresso machines are perfect for espresso purists who appreciate the ritualistic nature of manual brewing. Manual machines are favored by enthusiasts who prioritize craftsmanship and tradition.

CLEANING INFO
Manual machines require regular maintenance, including thorough cleaning of the lever mechanism, group head and portafilter.

PROS

  • Complete control over brewing variables

  • Produces rich and nuanced espresso shots

  • No reliance on electricity

CONS

  • Steeper learning curve

  • Requires physical effort to operate

additional espresso machine features

Now that you have guidance on the type of espresso machine you are looking for, you can dive deeper into specific features that will enhance your experience like built-in frothers or the ability to use coffee pods.

Home Espresso Machines with Frothers
For those who enjoy indulging in creamy lattes or velvety cappuccinos, consider machines equipped with milk frothers for barista-quality foam. Some machines have components for automatically frothing milk directly into the cup, or they might have steam wands that can be used to manually steam a smaller pitcher of milk to be poured into the final drink.

Home Espresso Machines with Grinders
Integrated grinders ensure freshly ground coffee beans with each brew, maximizing flavor and aroma for a truly exceptional cup of espresso. A built in grinder also means that you won’t need to have a separate grinder on your coffee bar, and often there is less mess with stray coffee grounds.

Combination espresso coffee machines
Love coffee and espresso? With a combination espresso machine, you don’t have to choose! These machines offer the ability to brew a traditional pot of coffee as well as pull a shot of espresso in one streamlined machine.

Pod espresso machines
If you are pressed for time in the morning or don’t like mess, a single serve espresso machine such as a pod-based machine might be what you are looking for. Premium espresso pods come in many options for specialty coffee and make quick, single-serve drinks with minimal cleanup. Some espresso pod machines also have milk frothing capabilities so you can still enjoy a morning latte.

additional features
popular brands

popular espresso maker brands

Breville
Renowned for innovation and precision, Breville offers a range of semi automatic espresso machines designed to elevate your coffee experience, including the small but mighty Breville Bambino.

DeLonghi
Combining Italian craftsmanship with cutting-edge technology, De’Longhi espresso machines deliver exceptional performance and style for discerning coffee enthusiasts.

Jura
Recognized for its Swiss engineering and premium quality, Jura fully automatic espresso machines boast advanced features and customizable options for the perfect brew every time.

SMEG
Inspired by retro aesthetics and also based in Italy, SMEG espresso machines blend style and functionality, adding a touch of vintage charm to your kitchen countertop.

Miele
Renowned for refined stylish and state-of-the-art engineering, Miele espresso machines offer performance and durability, for excellence in home espresso brewing.

Nespresso
With its sleek and compact designs, Nespresso brings convenience to the forefront, offering a wide selection of single-serve coffee & espresso machines compatible with Nespresso pods.

KitchenAid
KitchenAid has been creating high-quality kitchenware for over a century, and their espresso machines combine functionality with sleek design.

Bialetti
Celebrated for its iconic Moka pot design, Bialetti offers traditional stovetop espresso makers that evoke the authentic Italian coffee experience.

final thoughts

Choosing the right espresso machine is a decision that should be made with careful consideration of your brewing preferences, lifestyle and budget. Whether you opt for the convenience of an automatic machine or the versatility of semi automatic espresso machines, there's a perfect espresso maker out there for you.

For those interested in exploring a wider range of coffee options beyond espresso, be sure to check out our comprehensive buying guide on coffee makers. Happy brewing!

final thoughts
Espresso Guide

expert answers about espresso makers